Hurricane Ian is Ripping Apart Florida’s Property Insurance Industry
Expect a painful, costly cleanup effort after Hurricane Ian.
Now that Hurricane Ian has passed, millions of Floridians will be navigating a public-private insurance nightmare nearly as frightening as the storm that ravaged their state.
Over 2.5 million Floridians were without power as of Thursday morning, and NextEra Energy-owned Florida Power & Light is warning entire portions of its infrastructure are beyond repair. The storm could spur anywhere between $20 and $40 billion worth of property insurance claims, according to risk-modeling from RBC Capital Markets analysts. Worse, many Floridians aren’t even insured at all.
Riding the Storm Out
Florida is already a tough market for insurers. The private insurance industry has bled over $1 billion in each of the past two years, according to an Associated Press report, even as Florida citizens pay an average annual premium of $4,200 or three times the national average. With insurers abandoning the state and hundreds of thousands of residents dropped or priced out from the private market, the public insurer of last resort, Citizens Property Insurance, hit over 1 million policies this summer for the first time in nearly ten years.
Ahead of the storm, a Citizens spokesperson estimated Ian would lead to 225,000 claims and $3.8 billion in losses — but that program doesn’t even cover flood damage. The costs will be staggering:
- In counties home to the 2.5 million Floridians under mandatory evacuation, only 18.5% of homes had flood insurance, which is covered outside both private insurers and Citizens through the National Flood Insurance Program, actuarial firm Milliman told The New York Times. Just under 50% of homes inside the government-designated floodplain have flood insurance.
- Low levels of flood insurance coverage in these areas are likely to lead to longer and pricier rebuilds. “These people, many of them believe that their homeowners’ insurance policy will cover them,” said Nancy Watkins, principal and consulting actuary at Milliman, told NYT. “Or they might think that federal disaster aid is going to swoop in and make them whole.”
Don’t Count on FEMA: The federal agency may be great at paying for temporary housing or small repairs, but FEMA typically won’t rebuild homes wholesale — with aid generally limited to less than $40,000, according to an NYT report this summer.
Litigious Citizens: Perhaps unsurprisingly, Floridians lock horns with insurance companies more often than their fellow Americans elsewhere — by a longshot. From 2015 to 2020, Florida accounted for 8% of all homeowners insurance claims but nearly 80% of all homeowners’ lawsuits against insurers, the AP reports. The hurricane may have passed, but a legal storm has only just begun.